Why use dogs to study genes?

For thousands of years, dogs have been used by people in many roles. Over several hundred years, people have deliberately selected dogs with different characteristics to do different jobs.  

Dogs have been bred for many different characteristics:

  • physical attributes
    • coat color, height, weight, muscle mass, etc.
  • intelligence (Dog intelligence ratings)
  • instinctual behaviors
    • herding, tracking, retrieving, guarding, etc.
Picture of three dogs

Purebred dogs are true breeding lines, just like the pea varieties Mendel used to study inheritance.

So, just as Mendel used crosses between different types of peas to study inheritance of pea pod color and shape, scientists today can use crosses between different breeds of dogs to study the inheritance of physical attributes, intelligence and behaviors.

The Dog Genome Project is studying the inheritance of approximately 31 traits or characters. This is a collaborative project between scientists at the University of California at Berkley, the University of Oregon, and the Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center in Seattle, Washington. 

line separator

 

What dogs should be used in the crosses?

The Dog Genome Project crossed a Newfoundland with a border collie.  These two breeds exhibit many different behaviors. These two breeds are also descendant from the two most divergent groups of domesticated dogs.

Newfoundland

mother "Pepper"

Border Collie

father "Gregor"

newfie photo

border collie photo

easygoing, affectionate, water loving, loyal, extra large (~150 lbs), all black coat brainy, intense, workaholic, medium size (~35 lbs), black coat with white markings

line separator

 

Which traits are under investigation?

Trait/behavior

Newfoundland

Border Collie

size

extra large

medium

coat color

all black

black with white markings

showing eye

absent

strong

crouch

absent

strong

eye contact with owner

absent

strong

biddability

absent

strong

tail posture when running

held high

held low

barking at home

moderate

very low

running gait

bounding

sprint

scent vs sight

scent

sight

sensitivity to noise

insensitive

sensitive

water preference

high

low

people in water

attentive/intervening

indifferent

affection demands

high

low

sociability with other dogs

high

low

line separator

 

What were the results of the cross between Pepper and Gregor?

There have been two litters (these represent F1 generations).

Altogether there were seven puppies.  All the puppies grew up to look similar to one another, they were smaller than their mother and bigger than their father.  There were mostly all black like their mother.  All of them "showed eye" and displayed a crouch like their father, and were water loving like their mother.

line separator

 

What do these results tell you about the genes controlling size, coat color and behavior in the dogs?

 

line separator

 

What were the results of crosses among the F1 individuals?  

There are 23 F2 individuals.  Each dog was distinct from other F2 individuals. All of the F2 dogs were bigger or smaller than their F1 parents. There were more white markings on the F2s than on their F1 parents.

There were unique combinations of behaviors: one F2 showed eye, loved people and was indifferent to water, a second F2 carried his tail like a border collie, did not show eye, loved people but did not swim.

line separator

 

How many genes control the herding instinct in border collies?

The behaviors seen in individual F2s suggest that many genes control this behavior. Individual F2 dogs have different combinations of the components of the herding behavior. Selection of herding ability in early dogs by prehistoric peoples was probably a complex process.

line separator

 

Can these researchers determine where the genes are that control different traits?

Yes, DNA analyses are being conducted on all of the generations in this study: parents, F1 and F2 generations.  Those DNA markers which are only found in dogs that "show eye" are likely to be near the gene(s) for this behavior, similarly those DNA markers only found in dogs that have white markings are likely to be near the gene(s) for white coat color.  For more information about how to map genes read these online publications:

line separator

 

What traits would you want to study in dogs?  Which dogs or breed of dog would you use in your experiments?

 

For more information go to What is the Dog Genome Project?  or read Smithsonian Nov. 1996 pp. 126-137.


Return to:
| Dog Genome Workshop | | Molecular Biology| | Educational and Outreach Resources |

 

Please send comments and suggestions to: moconnel@nmsu.edu

Last Updated: July 10, 1998